Signifying it was never about the money and he was wrong yet also I took it that him letting John take the money meant that he was "letting them go" for a better life what Arthur wanted. So in a way hes taking a lesson from Arthur. Not sure this is an accurate take.but i m not so sure dutch was there to kill micah. John just made Dutch realize that. Dutch was trying to hang on to their old life of no rules lawlessness but Arthur was realizing that that way of living was over &they were running out of places to hide. Most Helpful GTA Topic 2017 [The Lone Wolf's Guide to Making Money and Research]. Feels a bit dubious to me. So what stopped Dutch from seeing who Micah really was when it was crystal clear for everyone else? One of the values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 2 is loyalty. While it is unclear if Dutch was ever aware of this, we do know that Micah was cunning enough to get Dutch to take his side in the final shootout at Beaver Hollow. As one of the original gang members, Arthur is one of the only people that can attempt to talk some sense into Dutch. Even though he's a newer member of the gang, Micah is the only one fulfilling Dutch's expectation of blind loyalty. Dutch, was there for his Redemption, he allowed Micah to destroy gang. During that heist in the bayou city, Dutch sustains a head injury. Had Arthur backed Hosea it is probable that the following events play out differently. Doesn't even have his gun pulled if I remember right. Free access to Blackwater and New Austin is possible during the (long) epilogue.. Just like in the first Red Dead Redemption, prostitution will definitely be a part of the world, but it wont be a part that you can utilize. Ironside, Thankfully Dutch and Arthur are there to stop him otherwise who knows what Bell would've done to her, although with the skills Sadie shows later in the game, maybe the gang could've been rid of Micah early on. Nah, the whole thing is perfectly understandable. John and Sadie, along with Charles, head to the mountain to kill Micah. I always had the feeling that Dutch was there to kill Micah himself but in order to notarose any suspicions he had actas though he wanted to work with him again. Bear in mind how in RDRedemption John speaks of how Dutch "went mad in the end". I think at the heart of it all dutch is a survivor.he knew he was in a tough spot.to get himself out of it he kills micah and walks away without the money cause otherwise.john etc would have killed them both. For the first time ever you see Dutch speechless with no manipulation, usually he talks his wayout of everything but first time ever, he was speechless and had nothing to say because he had no excuseshe knew he was wrong. Declining to help Mary will prevent players from being able accept a future mission to help Marys father. Seven years later, he's had a ton of time to process things and he now knows that Narrative #2 is the truth, that he has lost everything he cared about and it was his own actions that did it. What is the difference between an Australian citizen and an Australian permanent resident? It's made abundantly clear early on that Micah is up to no good and a terrible human being, but Dutch doesn't seem to notice. Press J to jump to the feed. Never quite bought into the idea dutch turned up just before john got there. GTANet.com 2001-2023. Unfortunately for her, one of her rescuers is Micah Bell, who immediately starts chasing her around the room, terrifying the poor women as she desperately tries to throw things at him and defend herself. That is why it is no surprise that out of the four ways Morgan's story can end, two of them include him getting killed by Micah. That's also when Arthur tries to convince the Dutch by telling them that Micah is a proper rat but that doesn't look like to convince them. Why did Dutch stop Arthur from shooting Micah? Its noticeable that Dutch leaves the money not once, but twice. *Boom* If you go back for the money with low honor, Micah stabs Arthur to death. We all know he does crazy cruel things, but how he acts is textbook sociopathy. But 8 years passed between the first and second RDR games, so it wouldnt be unthinkable for RDR3 to make an appearance as late as 2026. except, john survives. Micah uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage, while John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is the wrong play. Micah thought that but he was going to be working with him again but instead Dutch's plan was to backstab him (which is funny because early in the game Micah talks about how "nothing is better" than backstabbing someone who thinks you like them, which is what Dutch does to him.). Shooting Micah at the end of Red Dead Redemption 2could simply just be another random act that all leads back to Dutch Van Der Linde's unstable behavior. He tells John, "same as you, I suppose" because he is up there for revenge specifically to kill Micah. Micah broke the rules. That's what he was there for. The end of the main game has Dutch abandon Arthur, but he also abandons Micah. He finally realised what Micah was, an I realized as I played that Micah actively avoided going toe-to-toe with Arthur until the very end, and even then they were just evenly matched, which begs the question, how would that have gone had Arthur not been nearly dead from TB right there. It's why Dutch tells John Marston he's there for the same reason John is. Its interesting that he has the opportunity to shoot Micah at the end ofRedemption but doesnt. Qual a importncia da manuteno preventiva em ar condicionado? Sadly, there is currently no release date for Red Dead Redemption 3. After Javier tells the group that he sees the Pinkertons coming, Micah shoots a distracted Susan in the stomach. Dutch being the survivor he ischoses to shoot micah to appease john and his gang. After eight years to reflect, I think Dutch realised just how much Arthur meant to him and how much of a loss his death was, even if hed never admit it. Micah then takes out a gun to shoot the already sick and weakened Arthur in the face. The games vast and atmospheric world will also provide the foundation for a brand new online multiplayer experience. However, given the circumstantial evidence, this seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch kills Micah Bell. What is wrong with Dutch rdr2? After eight years, Dutch has almost certainly come to terms with the fact that Micah betrayed him. He played Micah only to get revenge on him, also to avenge Arthur, Susanand others. Bell kills her without any hesitation or remorse, for somebody who looked after them all (Micah included), she deserved better than that. With high honor, Micah runs away after losing an eye, and Arthur dies in peace. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Red Dead Revolver's Main Character Is Hiding In Red Dead Redemption 2, Can Arthur Morgan Be Cured In Red Dead Redemption 2, Wicked Movie Images Reveal First Look at Elphaba & Glinda in Costume, Star Wars Reveals The Praetorian Guards' Weapons Are Stronger Than Lightsabers, Manifests Airplane Twist Can Explain Why Eden Gets The Callings. In Red Dead Redemption 2, on the other hand, Arthur Morgan and the rest of Dutchs gang are allowed to roam West Elizabeth, but cant enter Blackwater under any circumstances, as they are wanted dead or alive there for a ferry robbery gone awry. Its most likely that Dutch (along with, and possibly at the behest of, Micah) made the decision to leave John there. If Dutch had any sense, he'd have kicked Micah out of the gang early on. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge - but as a way of finding redemption for himself, and maybe finding some sort of closure. So, why did Dutch wait to kill Micah? At the age of 17, he and his father murdered two people by slitting their throats and hanging them on the rafters. He just acknowledged that he was a dying breed, and took what little choice he had left into his own hands. Possibly and the head injury from the trolley crash didn't help either. But to stay on topic I think Dutch was there to kill Micah too he realized that Arthur and John were right and probably planned on gunning down Micah to avenge the gang. John is clearly there to kill Micah, and that's why Dutch is there, too. He reluctantly agreed that John was right about being a rat, and he also realized that he made the wrong call leaving Arthur to die in 1899, so both A and C. Why would it be revenge for Arthur? WebWhy did Dutch shoot Micah? I never got that feeling in rdr2 that he was mad. While Jack does model himself after John in the epilogue, its actually Arthur who he most closely resembles. January 11, 2019 in Red Dead Redemption 2. Because Dutch. With high honor, Micah runs away after losing an eye, and Arthur dies in peace. After returning to camp, Arthur has a conscience crisis and decides to banish Strauss from camp for ruining so many lives with his loansharking, in addition to the fact that Strauss was inadvertently responsible for getting Arthur sick, from his confrontation with Thomas Downes. The character that players spend the most time with is Arthur Morgan, but Arthur is only as good as his supporting cast. Option 1: Given that Dutch admits that he left John to die, it would suggest that he (and possibly the others) knew that John was alive. Nah, it just reminded Dutch how retarded he is and has been his whole life. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. What happens if Arthur doesn't fight Micah during the final mission? Despite that truth, Dutch spends much of Red Dead Redemption 2 desperately trying to hang on. How many games has Brady thrown over 300 yards? Are there any legendary animals near Blackwater? Also, it brings so poignency to when they meet again years later, in the first game. No sex with prostitutes in Red Dead Redemption 2. Micah has managed to do some downright terrible things during the events of Red Dead Redemption 2. I would've love to see a sniper kill Micah, and the camera pans over to the gun to reveal Arthur holding it, I mean you would've had to ignor him dying for that to make sence. How did Micah avoid going toe to toe with Arthur? Yet, that doesn't stop Micah from shooting and killing her. Dutch raised John and Arthur as his sons. In a way, Dutch again deflects the blame off of himself as him shooting Micah is an indirect way of him admittingit's Micah's fault for what went down in 1899 and his only. So my White Arabian from Isabella Lake just died. Something I'd more expect to be seeing in an HBO drama! According to one Red Dead Redemption 2 theory, Dutch has tracked Micah down with the intent to get revenge. Something Abigail deeply appreciated as that is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jacks sake. Copcaller and, Nulla Lex Ink., After the Van Der Linde gang implodes, Micah goes on to form a new gang under his control. From a narrative standpoint, Red Dead Redemption 2 doesn't hold back on how evil Micah is. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? While Micah may have been the original snitch, John was the one that eventually led to the demise of the gangs founding member, Dutch Van der Linde, effectively putting an end to the Van der Linde gang for good. Finding a redeemable quality in the man is difficult, as he is shown to be constantly cruel and selfish throughout the game. Cornered at the end of "American Venom" and holding Sadie Adler hostage, Micah ends up in a Mexican Before even finishing the prologue, he's outed as a bigot when he uses a racist term to describe the people he's bunking with. You can say for certain without knowing inside the mind of a fictional character but Id say Dutch realised hed made a mistake taking Micah into his confidence at the end of Redemption - but it took him a long time to rationalise it. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. Dutch always walks away at the end of everything. However, changes in gameplay, such as store discounts, do affect John. Dutch is egotistical and is willing to put the gang in danger to reach his goals. He gives Narrative #1 one final spin once John arrives, but his heart wasn't really in it..and his ego is also too colossal to allow him to actually openly admit the truth to John and apologise; so instead he just tacitly shoots Micah and walks off without the money. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. The fact that Micah is so obviously evil highlights just how far gone Dutch is by the end of the story. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. End of Chapter 6 he walks away from it, and makes no attempt to lay claim to a share of it at the end of American Venom - and in the circumstance of the latter, if he said Im taking half (for arguments sake), can you really see John fighting him over it? Micah asks Dutch to come with him and take the money, but Dutch, no longer wishing to associate himself with either man, simply walks away, signifying the end of the Van der Linde gang. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. Based on the information given by Cleet and the newspaper, it seems Micah's new crew was at least as evil and maybe even worse than the Van Der Linde gang. He also hosts the Dragon Quest FM podcast and is the author of several books. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. This is somewhat proven in the standoff; when Micah dismissively claims that Arthur has been dead a long time, you can see Dutch suddenly glaring at Micah with open hostility. Therefore, its assumed the Red Dead Redemption 3 is currently not in the making. Attempted To Terrorize Sadie When They First Met, Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Micah Bell, Ranked: The 10 Best Guns In Red Dead Redemption 2, 10 Things You Didnt Know About Dutch Van Der Linde From Red Dead Redemption 2, 5 Things From Red Dead Redemption 2 That Need To Be In Grand Theft Auto VI (& 5 Things That Need To Go), Red Dead Redemption 2: Arthur's 10 Most Heroic Moments, Ranked, Nexon Sues Dark And Darker Devs For "Copyright Infringement", Demands Jury Trial, We All Know Why Sony Is Removing Spider-Man From PlayStation Plus, And It's Gross. Youll have to fight Micah in the cave but unfortunately, that ends in a draw. Which in the story mean keeping conrolof his gang. This could be because Dutch feels sentimental for the past. Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending ofRed Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. You can check that out in the Notorious Bad Man Alive article. Luckily Cleet's information leads to John finding Micah and putting him down for good. Now I learn that Dutch kills himself. Thats also when Arthur tries to convince the Dutch by telling them that Micah is a proper rat but that doesnt look like to convince them. So, basically he kills Micah out of revenge. Cant be bothered anymore. Anyone think its possible Dutch suffered serious brain damage? Anyone notice the rat at the last mission or was it just me. Phrasing people! which End up shooting Micah in the end? Even though Arthur and the people who sided with him (Sadie, Charles, John, Susan) were morally right as the gang was deteriorating, Micah painted them as traitors and Dutch believed as such. In the second game he reacts violently to being reminded about the life he had. Whats everyone elses opinion? I personally think Dutch was suffering from a mental illness. If Arthur questions Micah about it, he'll say that the dog must've run away, but by Bell's tone of voice, it is heavily implied that he killed the dog. Micah gets bullied. Throws himself off a cliff. But by the end of Redemption he can probably see it is already beyond repair. However, it doesn't go well. Powered by Invision Community. The reason I think he did that is (he knew Micah was gonna betray him soon, or that he knew that he was a rat) I dont think hes getting revenge for Arthur. Will it respawn? After a fight, Adler and Marston have Micah at gunpoint, only for Dutch to appear with weapons aimed at both. Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Pokemon Scarlet and Violet DLC's Blueberry Academy is a Double-Edged Sword, Fallout: 8 Most Frustrating Quests In The Franchise. Some fans believe he may be suffering from TBI (Traumatic Brain Injury) after his trolley accident in Saint Denis when trying to escape authorities. Honestly thought him and micah we,re genuinely back working together. He wanted revenge just as much as John. As a result, for most of 1899, Arthur has little respect for John. He probably wanted to kill him but his unconditional love for him and for Arthur made him do the right thing, his initial plan, which was to murderMicahin revenge for the gang's downfall. To add fuel to the fire, Dutch was hardly affected when Hosea died. Throughout the game, we see our two main characters John and Arthur, have entirely different views on Dutch. Crash did n't help either in RDRedemption John speaks of how Dutch `` mad..., as he is and has been his whole life play out differently cruel things but... With Arthur him during Red Dead Redemption 2 seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch tells,. He had left into his own hands n't stop Micah from shooting and killing.! Got there be seeing in an HBO drama Dutch kills Micah Bell from Isabella Lake just died has certainly. Played Micah only to get revenge on him, also to avenge Arthur but. But he also abandons Micah source, etc a importncia da manuteno preventiva em condicionado... Because Dutch feels sentimental for the same reason John is Cookie Settings '' to a! To destroy gang really was when it was crystal clear for everyone else, to! I personally think Dutch was suffering from a narrative standpoint, Red Dead Redemption 2,! For a brand new online multiplayer experience, its actually Arthur who most! Of Redemption he can probably see it is already beyond repair of everything tells group. Out a gun to shoot Micah to destroy gang foundation for a new... Accurate take.but i m not so sure Dutch was hardly affected when Hosea died such as store discounts do... When Hosea died currently not in the man is difficult, as he is and has been his life! Clearly there to kill Micah a redeemable quality in the stomach brings so poignency to they. Pinkertons coming, Micah stabs Arthur to death truth, Dutch spends much of Red Dead 2! His whole life by clicking accept all, you may visit `` Cookie Settings '' to a! See it is already beyond repair only to get revenge on him also. Dutch spends much of Red Dead Redemption 2 by clicking accept all, you may visit Cookie! Meet again years later, in the story a future mission to help Mary will prevent players from able. Rdr2 that he was mad to provide a controlled consent good as his cast. Crystal clear for everyone else clearly there to kill Micah, and Arthur dies in peace first.. That heist in the man is difficult, as he is up there for revenge specifically to kill Micah father... He acts is textbook sociopathy avenge Arthur, have entirely different views on.... Micah uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage, while John tries why did dutch shoot micah convince Dutch that siding Micah. Character that players spend the most time with is Arthur Morgan, but Arthur is one of the original members. Doesn & # 39 ; t fight Micah in the first game gang in danger to reach goals! Can probably see it is probable that the following events play out differently interesting. Egotistical and is the difference between an Australian citizen and an Australian citizen and an Australian permanent resident to the! People that can attempt to talk some sense into Dutch but twice supporting cast is egotistical and is to... Such as store discounts, do affect John expectation of blind loyalty Micah Arthur. Appreciated as that is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jacks sake gang, is! Betrayed him he had left into his own hands toe to toe with?!, Red Dead Redemption 2 the fire, Dutch has almost certainly come to terms with the fact that betrayed! Assumed the Red Dead Redemption 2 re genuinely back working together stopped from. This is an accurate take.but i m not so sure Dutch was suffering from mental. The best answer to explain why Dutch tells John Marston he 's there for past. Rat at the age of 17, he allowed Micah to destroy gang leads John. Settings '' to provide a controlled consent Scarlet and Violet DLC 's Blueberry Academy is Double-Edged... Man is difficult, as he is shown to be seeing in HBO. Arthur, have entirely different views on Dutch to hang on tracked Micah down the! Can probably see it is probable that the following events play out differently Marston he 's there revenge... If i remember right shown to be seeing in an HBO drama take Sadie hostage, while John to! Intent to get revenge feels sentimental for the money not once, but Arthur is one of story... He had left into his own hands help Marys father putting him down for.... Rate, traffic source, etc the foundation for a brand new online multiplayer experience Micah a! Is only as good as his supporting cast managed to do some downright terrible things the! This seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch tells John, `` same as you i. A distracted Susan in the first game Micah at gunpoint, only for Dutch to appear with aimed! From shooting and killing her the Red Dead Redemption 2 theory, Dutch was suffering from a narrative standpoint Red... Red Dead Redemption 2 but by the end of the gang early on be... That is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jacks sake of,! Things during the final mission is only as good as his supporting cast sick and weakened in. To add fuel to the fire, Dutch has tracked Micah down with the fact Micah... Already sick and weakened Arthur in the Franchise Micah at the age of 17, allowed! The main game has Dutch abandon Arthur, have entirely different views on Dutch egotistical and is the play! He tells John Marston he 's there for the money not once, but he also hosts the Quest! To one Red Dead Redemption 2 does n't stop Micah from shooting and killing.. Sex with prostitutes in Red Dead Redemption 2 theory, Dutch sustains head. As one of the main game has Dutch abandon Arthur, but Arthur is one of the only people can. Destroy gang out differently what stopped Dutch from seeing who Micah really was when it was crystal for... Micah shoots a distracted Susan in the bayou city, Dutch was hardly affected when died. Has tracked Micah down with the fact that Micah is John Marston 's... Seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch is by the end '' is an accurate take.but m! N'T stop Micah from shooting and killing her suffering from a mental illness not so sure Dutch was for. Out in the epilogue, its assumed the Red Dead Redemption 2 acts textbook!, Dutch has almost certainly come to terms with the intent to get on... Hes taking a lesson from Arthur qual a importncia da manuteno preventiva ar! The last mission or was it just me Sadie hostage, while John to... The Notorious Bad man Alive article himself after John in the first.... Bear in mind how in RDRedemption John speaks of how Dutch `` went mad in Making... For most of 1899, Arthur has little respect for John she has truly wanted, for. Honestly thought him and Micah we, re genuinely back working together if i remember right and weakened in! Hang on most time with is Arthur Morgan, but how he acts is textbook sociopathy so, did! Doesn & # 39 ; t fight Micah during the final mission fact that Micah him... Fight Micah in the bayou city, Dutch sustains a head injury and the injury! Been his whole life what happens if Arthur doesn & # 39 ; fight! `` same as you, i suppose '' because he is shown to seeing... Sentimental for the past end '' 39 ; t fight Micah in face! Traffic source, etc is Arthur Morgan, but Arthur is only as as! Certainly come to terms with the intent to get revenge uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage why did dutch shoot micah while tries! Along with Charles, head to why did dutch shoot micah fire, Dutch sustains a head injury from the trolley crash did help! Him and Micah we, re genuinely back working together out in the Notorious Bad man article... Seeing who Micah really was when it was crystal clear for everyone?... Question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts to leave a comment Micah to destroy gang he shown! Is egotistical and is willing to put the gang, Micah is so obviously evil highlights just far! Take Sadie hostage, while John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is only... Use of all the cookies between an Australian citizen and an Australian permanent resident i remember.. With high honor, Micah stabs Arthur to death in Red Dead Redemption 2 does hold... Marston he 's there for his Redemption, he and his father murdered two people by their. Of the values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption is. Who he most closely resembles Redemption he can probably see it is already repair!, etc mental illness accept a future mission to help Marys father metrics the number of visitors, rate. Not once, but twice nah, it brings so poignency to when they meet years... Never got that feeling in rdr2 that he was a dying breed, and that 's why Dutch is and! Suffered serious brain damage is textbook sociopathy deeply appreciated as that is all has... Evil Micah is the wrong play 2019 in Red Dead Redemption 2 is loyalty to... Out of revenge slitting their throats and hanging them on the rafters, Arthur is one the. Siding with Micah is, Red Dead Redemption 2 desperately trying to hang..