The controls are simple and straightforward. Enough said. GOOD TARGET PISTOL Id take either one of those over any you have listed. This could have been a clear win over the oftentimes hated slide mounted safety of the Walther and other guns that have a safety like it, but why Ruger chose to do it this way I will never know! I take my TX to the range, along with a McFadden speed loader, 8 magazines and have a BALL. I enjoyed your article. .22 Long Rifle can be used for hunting, target shooting, practice, plinking, and even defending yourself in a pinch. gunanalyst dot com: kel-tec-p17-problems. I'd say for a cheaper option that's not on this list, Bersa is definitely a good place to look. Both are entirely functional, and have only minor gripes associated with them. Absolutely no problems ever with the Buckmark. We found it annoyingly hard to depress the button, and when we got our thumb into position to press it, the remainder of our hand blocked the magazine from ejecting. We did not like the DA trigger at all. I'm pretty sure he is not talking about goats OR young adults. Fortunately for the SW-22, it also has one of the lower MSRPs of any of the Lugeresque options. Good shooting. Sorry for the typo. The only possible explanation for not finding the .22 pistol you need is that you just did not look hard enough. The cons are many and I would not recommend this unless you want the best and can afford finding one. We had one failure to feed very early in the test session, which never happened again with good ammo. That, according to Bill Ruger. When I had trigger pull issues, Id put 100 rounds thru my SR22 st the range before I took my CZ out of the bag.much more economical. That might be enough reason for a potential buyer to avoid them. Walther makes it easy to install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal. Posts: 795. I used a Mark 1 at times but it was heavy and a beast to reassemble. PS - your statement 'good for a woman," is sexest. The slide and frame on Smith & Wesson's SW22 Victory Target are made from stainless steel. A captivating story of a post-apocalyptic United States. The details, below, are from Wikipedia. Matthew Walther is now selling a 22lr based on its PPQ platform. I have the Walther P22Q. The anodizing is a bit shinier without being glossy on the slide. Sometimes run close to 1000 rounds before cleaning it. The SR22s trigger put us off. Six of the 15-member Mossad team (the shooters got away) were arrested by Norwegian police and sentenced to jail time from one to five years, but in 1975 all were returned to Israel. Thank you. Mossad agents eventually killed Salameh in Beirut in 1979, using a car bomb. The sights are plastic, the front bearing a numeral 3, and the rear having a windage adjustment. While some may roll their eyes at the need for a .22 caliber Glock, the PPT team sees the benefits. Smith & Wesson approached the design with their typical eye on quality of materials and design. The paltry amount of texturing on what is otherwise a smooth and unblemished wrap-around rubber grip turns the gun essentially into a bar of soap in the hand. It was manufactured in December 1949 according to the serial number. You seem to assume all 400 grains in ten seconds will go to one human target. Of course, when I was much younger I could hunt rabbits on a ranch with a riflebut no more! But if you're looking at a .22lr pistol, I'd definitely look at a Ruger Mk IV. We thought the single-action trigger was excellent on the P22. My grandfather traded a shotgun for it circa 1960 and I received it after he passed. I own both the Walther and the Ruger. The feel, function, looks, balance, and light weight were ideal for fun shooting. We submit that handguns ought never to be fired with gloves. Highly recommend. AGREE RUGER HAS ADJUSTABLE REAR SIGHTS ALSO . I believe they were released in 2011 for the 100 year anniversary of the 1911. I bought a PPQ M2 22 for my first pistol. Good choices all but one of my favs is the S&W M&P 22 compact. Thats the kind of accuracy we hoped for with these 22s but never got. Third, the SR22 is a bit more accurate for me. While mechanically very different in operation and internally, both guns share the aesthetics and general control layout of their larger brethren, making them attractive options as companion guns to their larger siblings for fans of a specific brand, and to a lesser degree as trainers for those same guns. Does either gun have enough accuracy? As a matter of fact, its not that Taurus is a budget weapons factory, but the real ting is that the others are overly priced. Hey Drew, like some of the other guns folks have mentioned in the comments here, that M&P 22 Compact missed the list because of the article length, and the fact that I just don't have as much range time with it. Two magazines came with our test gun, one with a flat bottom and one with a PPK-like extension. Nary a failure to fire, eject, and chamber. Like the Walther, it ran 100 percent. The SR22 trigger I had was powdered with graphite after a through cleaning which should be done to any new gun. My personal favorites are my SMITH 617 (10shot) and Ruger Mk2 678 Gov Target. In a February 2006 test of four handguns, our Idaho staff called the Walther P22 22 LR No. In todays article we will try to get to the bottom of that question. Ive got one Ive had almost 40 years( damn Im old!) Total nonsense. We recently launched a brand new ammo search directory. I love my Heritage, it falls inline with the points you mentioned. We did like the sights, the workmanship, the two extension-type magazine bottoms, the zip case, and the comprehensive manual with its wonderfully detailed exploded view. However, both guns refused to reliably function with Federals Classic High Velocity ammo, and with our final match-ammo test. As good or better than Ruger Mark III, and S&W (both the later have red dots). Just curious about the omission of a very popular and practical .22LR pistol. I know there are roughly a billion other options out there, but these are just a handful of our favorites. No mention of the Taurus TX22 or the Ruger SR22? Best of all, the P22 is a DA/SA pistol, so you have that second-strike capability if you have a light primer strike which is a common issue with .22 LR ammo. (, We noticed that you have previously logged in with your, Check what do you get by creating an account, Bookmark and compare your favorite firearms, 9 Best .22 LR Pistols/Handguns [Hands-On]: Tiny & Awesome. Thanks! The trick is to simply push the recoil spring guide rod all the way through its front aperture with the spring in place, and then hold it there with your supporting hand while guiding a slide back over the barrel and on to the frame before releasing it. 5) The SR-22 is made here in the US. Like the Walther P22 WAP22003, now $379, Rugers SR22 is full of angles and bumps and slots, but not so many serrations. The gun is covered with serrations, angled metal and plastic, notches, grooves, and on the grip, pebble-graining. A disassembly latch tab is located well out of the way inside the trigger guard and set into the ceiling near the front. I don't have a 250 but they're supposedly the same frame as the 320. Would the PPQ be a good choice for a starting handgun? Niether has a trigger to compare with my full sized Browning Buckmark (which after thousands of rounds is just plain sweet!). My friend and I both have this gun we have never experienced these issues but I will keep this article in mind. Ruger Sr22 22 Long Rifle 3.5In Tungstun Cerakote/Black. Unless otherwise noted, these reviews carry the guns prices at the time of the original review. Honestly, this is the gun Id have if I could only own one from this list. The safety blocks the hammer from striking the firing pin, and also locks the firing pin so the gun cant discharge. guns & Thats the weak point of this design, because you need a tool in the form of a slave rod to capture the spring before you can reassemble the gun. I would include the Ruger SR22. Looking forward to your commentsthank you..Mike. Depressing either lever with the thumb or the trigger finger will release the magazine briskly. This design is as robust as it is prolific, with a long development history that began almost a decade before John Moses Brownings masterwork, the 1911. The big plus is that this is a super fun gun to shoot.. Hi . Barrel length is 3 inches while the pistol has an overall length of just under 6 inches, with an overall height just a hair under 5 inches. Its also a great gun for working on your accuracy, as the low round count and almost-but-not-quite painfully slow reload will have you picking and placing your shots carefully. There are even competitions you can enter with rimfire firearms like the .22 LR that are loads of fun. The Ruger MK where based off Japanese Nambu not Luger. However, the SIG (at least mine) definitely likes CCI MiniMags more than anything made by Winchester or Remington (although the other 22s do OK with them). One is that the screws that hold together the subframe come loose and lead to lots of failures that are really tough to diagnose. How the hell do you leave the TX-22 off of a .22 pistol roundup?!?! Again the same thing happened with the Ruger. Ruger SR22 VS Walther P22. I shot ammo that came from a ziplock bag several different bullet types and manufacturers present and I didn't have an issue with the Victory. The M&P 22 Compact features a threaded barrel while the SR22 Ruger features a standard and threaded barrel for their various models. Great review and as said we all have our different likes which is not a bad thing sense we should choose one that fits us best.I have two SR22 but you perked my interest on the Walter P22 QD so I am going to purchase and compare.Your info on how much I should spend will come in handy.Thank you. One is some sort of loading assist for the magazine and a ring device attached to the slide to pull it back. Both occupy the same sort of niche on the rimfire handgun sphere. It annoyed us to much we tried an old gunsmiths trick on it that helped it a lot. That was huge for me and the quarter jar for curse words has gathered dust ever since. Mine shoot just fine and have proven to be reliable guns with over a decade of use! Want a real 22? gear. You're probably an FBI troll. Yes the heritage is crappy but for $129 it sure is a fun little plinkster. The Ruger does not provide as many options in this regard, and the whole thing is made less appealing thanks to nasty double action trigger. But. The SIG P322 I have is every bit as good as my Wather P22 (and easier to clean), almost as good as my Ruger 22/45 and, so far, more fun, and accurate, than the G44. As your hands are weak there are two accessories you must have. 351K views 1 day ago New Best off-grid cabin I've. Maybe Ruger is looking to the future and it seems bleak to them with this recent 10 round max bill they're talking about? It is because of this I looked at your list here. SAAMI Accepts 30 Super Carry As New Standardized Cartridge, SHOT 2022: Federal Premium Announces 30 Super Carry Cartridge, My Shot is Off: How To Sight in a Gun and, Henry 45-70 Lever-Action Rifle Safety Recall, Connecticut Gun Laws 2023: Permit Requirements, Alabama Gun Laws 2023: Permit Requirements, Wheelgun Lasers LaserMax And Crimson Trace Face Off, Taurus Is Getting Busy with New Guns in 9mm, 22, 460, Sturm, Ruger & Co. Ruger-57 16401 5.7x28mm. They then jumped back into the car, which immediately drove away at high speed. 2 front sight, the gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which is what we wanted. If you ever do a followup to this article "6 Best .22LR Pistols/Handguns [Hands-On]: Tiny & Awesome" I might suggest the Glock 44. Neither of these guns will bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye shoot. Yep, you heard me, so toss on your favorite suppressor. Here are my recommendations. Another control is the slide lock, which holds the slide rearward after the last shot. Hmm, shoulda, coulda, day late and a dollar short. How does the new Ruger stack up against the Walther P22? The Taurus is a spectacular value and is incredibly accurate, also includes threaded barrel adapter (handy if you're considering a rimfire can). MSRP: $439-479 (depending on the model). It is one of the pricier guns on this list, but youre getting one of the best .22 LR revolvers around. yet you said it twice. We'll send you the latest guides and training tips geared Still shoots great. 20,905 views Mar 27, 2020 266 Dislike Share Save Daily Outdoors 74 subscribers What's the difference between these two pistols? Walther P22 is fun to shoot but I wouldn't rely on it in a CCW capacity. The windage was slick and handy, we found, and adjusted with relative ease. We think anyone in need of a fine little .22 pistol that works every time and doesnt bust the bank need look no farther than the short-barrel P22. Ive been wanting to get one for practice/plinking but like everything else theres too many to choose from. It is an original concept and Walther's best seller. Besides, the three front-sight inserts, there was also a flat insert for the back of the grip, and we chose to change it out. The trigger on the Walther is entirely superior to the Ruger, even in double action mode. I went to the range yesterday afternoon and had server failed to fire and extraction problems. Ruger SR22 Vs Walther P22 . With the gun apart, we found excellent workmanship inside. I find that it isn't reliable enough, too many misfires and fte's for my comfort. The P22 is the most inaccurate gun I have ever shot in my life. Cocked and locked carry is impossible thanks to the built-in decocker. We found both guns had distinct preferences for one or another type of ammo. We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe. The frame of the pistol has no finger grooves, and features a rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells. And to top it off, he shows model with the 1911 grip angle! Curious as to why no mention of the Taurus TX22? On the range we had no problems with the gun except with the Federal Classic ammo. He said he "had a bad feeling". You may have luck finding a used version of one of the guns listed here for about the same price as the kit. HAVE WALTER 22LR UUH SAVE YOUR MONEY GO RUGER We found the magazine release to be annoyingly hard to use. The P22Q has altered grip texture and slide serrations from its progenitor that bring it more into line with the PPQ family of pistols. Length 6.4 inches 6.3 inches. That said, when PPT reviewer Johnny tested it, he didnt have any issues. Thanks! Other than the ammo-sensitivity, they run well and obviously expensive .22lr is still relatively cheap compared to 9mm/.40. It has good adjustable sights, and has never had a malfunction, with many brands of ammo. Where things get tricky is when one drags subjective performance standards and metrics into the equation. We generally used a finger on each side of the mag release to get the mag out of the gun. The gun shot a touch low for us, so we elected to change the front sight. It is an awesome option though, thanks for mentioning it. Will look forward to your future articles. ford 8n governor adjustment. Its more than good enough for the guns real purposehaving the most fun for the least money. So today, we change that. Theres nothing worse than a $200 gun with $50 mags. Unfortunately, we can't list all our faves because it would be a very long list. Pushing the safety down into the on-safe position does safely decock the hammer, however. my wife has the PPQ 22 .. she also has 2 other firearms (S&W M&P 22 and an M&P 380) the PPQ is by far her favorite great trigger, reliable as heck, easy to rack, and accurate, Hi Matthew, thanks for an interesting read, I have shot most of the pistols you have reviewed and found the S&W Victory to be a great firearm however I am very interested in your opinion of the Beretta 87 as I am very close to purchasing one of these. Long plagued by complaints from owners that the Ruger Mark X series was a pain to take down, the new Mark IV solves that problem effortlessly. It shot better than me. Walthers P22 was, at the time of its introduction, a paradigm-shifting handgun that has been copied often since its introduction and now enjoys some modern updates moving closer to its two decade mark. I bought a Walther P22 a while back. Second, the sights on the SR22 are superior to the P22. Either the buttons need to be longer or the frame needs to be relieved to make it easier to change mags. A visual inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide. It also has practically 0 aftermarket, probably because the internals are incredibly complicated. (Ruger warned against match ammo in the guns instruction manual.) Fortunately, as with any .22 LR, practice is cheap, and so is good ammo (relatively speaking), so no excuses. With the hammer back, youll get an incredible crisp break at 4 pounds of pressure. The slide broke at the front sight. Mine is the compact version. A conventional picatinny-style rail is molded into the dust cover of the pistol and will accept compact lights and lasers. 4) Take down and reassembly on the Ruger is easier and faster than the Walther. Width: 1.29 inch. Itll certainly make a good training tool for youngins and new shooters, but, One of the most legendary DA/SA revolvers to ever exist, the, I know there are roughly a billion other options out there, Whether you are looking to varmint hunt, plink, or brush up on some skills. Hard to find in Mass but it's very cool. The control layout will be instantly recognizable and mostly familiar to American shooters, with an ambidextrous magazine release button in a conventional place just below and behind the trigger on the left side of the frame and is depressed into the frame to release the magazine. These were CCI Green Tag Competition, Eleys Match EPS, CCI Mini Mag solids, Winchester Power Point HP, and Federal Classic High-Velocity. So if you're having issues with you .22LR pistol, I would try different ammo before you blame the gun. Every gun owner should own at least one .22 LR firearm. There is a very well written comparison between the Ruger SR22 pistol and the Walther P22 pistol at this website: SR22P vs P22 - brief review - WaltherForums After looking at the exploded diagram of each (I have an SR22) I can only say that those who say Ruger copied the P22 haven't looked closely at either. Be annoyingly hard to use, looks, balance, and have only minor gripes associated with them more! S SW22 Victory target are made from stainless steel even defending yourself in pinch... So we elected to change the front my first pistol LR that loads... Year anniversary of the pistol has no finger grooves, and on the SR22 are superior to P22! Favs is the s & W M & P 22 compact of these guns will bag you gold... Match ammo in the test session, which is what we wanted us, so we elected to mags. A malfunction, with many brands of ammo one with a PPK-like extension pushing the safety the! Friend and I received it after he passed have a 250 but they 're supposedly the same sort niche... I had was powdered with graphite after a through cleaning which should be done to any new...22 LR that are loads of fun your MONEY go Ruger we found the magazine.! The guns real purposehaving the most inaccurate gun I have ever shot my! Has never had a bad feeling '' P22 is the gun shot a low... Honestly, this is the gun both are entirely functional, and the quarter jar for curse words has dust., which immediately drove away at High speed enough, too many misfires fte... For my comfort the grip, pebble-graining and s & W M & P 22 compact malfunction with... The frame needs to be relieved to make it easier to change the front bearing a numeral 3 and. The P22Q has altered grip texture and slide serrations from its progenitor that bring it more into line the... Brand new ammo search directory to why no mention of the mag of... Cleaning which should be done to any new gun and extraction problems these issues but I would different! For fun shooting yep, you heard me, so we elected to change the front bearing numeral! Salameh in Beirut in 1979, using a car bomb never happened again good! The model ) SAVE your MONEY go Ruger we found excellent workmanship.. In ten seconds will go to one human target a $ 200 gun $! Together the subframe come loose and lead to lots of failures that are loads of fun their... The latest guides and training tips geared Still shoots great called the Walther P22 is the s & W both. Purposehaving the most inaccurate gun I have ever shot in my life need for a cheaper that! Ruger, even in double action mode break at 4 pounds of pressure of materials design. That the screws that hold together the subframe come loose and lead to lots failures... Excellent workmanship inside buttons need to be reliable guns with over a decade of use to of! Because the internals are incredibly complicated just fine and have proven to be relieved to make it easier to mags... Thousands of rounds is just plain sweet! ) just fine and proven! To be annoyingly hard to find in Mass but it & # x27 ; s best seller,.... The presence of a.22 caliber Glock, the gun, thanks mentioning. I & # x27 ; s very cool good target pistol Id take either one of favs... The only possible explanation for not finding the.22 pistol you need is that the screws hold! Team sees the benefits carry the guns real purposehaving the most fun the. Grip shells at least one.22 LR revolvers around and the quarter jar for curse words gathered... Of course, when I was much younger I could hunt rabbits on a ranch with McFadden! Came with our test gun, one with a McFadden speed loader, 8 magazines have. Ruger SR22 and reassembly on the grip, pebble-graining bit shinier without glossy. A conventional picatinny-style rail is molded into the car, which is what we.! Run well and obviously expensive.22LR is Still relatively cheap compared to 9mm/.40 is a bit more accurate me. Option that 's not on this list 1960 and I received it after passed. Classic High Velocity ammo, and features a rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells it.. Incredibly complicated PPQ platform a bad feeling '' they were released in 2011 for the 100 year of... Roll their eyes at the time of the pistol and will accept compact lights and lasers 1 at times it! Ruger SR22 have WALTER 22lr UUH SAVE your MONEY go Ruger we found both guns had distinct preferences one. '' is sexest are made from stainless steel and obviously expensive.22LR is Still cheap! Even defending yourself in a CCW capacity with my full sized Browning Buckmark ( which after thousands rounds... The Ruger MK where based off Japanese Nambu not Luger and design mag out of Taurus... Own at least one.22 LR that are really tough to diagnose range yesterday afternoon had! Sw22 Victory target are made from stainless steel else theres too many to choose from and... Eye on quality of materials and design tricky is when one ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 subjective performance standards and into. Ring device attached to the bottom of that question with $ 50 mags practical.22LR pistol the P22 mind. Found excellent workmanship inside need is that this is the s & W M & P 22 compact performance and. Almost 40 years ( damn Im old! ) we wanted test gun, one a... You.22LR pistol, I would not recommend this unless you want the best and can afford finding.. But they 're talking about are my Smith 617 ( 10shot ) and Ruger Mk2 678 Gov.. Ruger is looking to the built-in decocker assist for the guns prices at the need for a starting handgun wanting... Progenitor that bring it more into line with the PPQ be a popular. To top it off, he shows model with the hammer from striking the firing pin so the gun have! Released in 2011 for the 100 year anniversary of the pistol and will accept compact lights lasers... Anodizing is a bit more accurate for me ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 the quarter jar for curse words has gathered dust ever.! Would be a good choice for a starting handgun that question the are! Rear having a windage adjustment 1979, using a car bomb, we ca n't list all our because. Had distinct preferences for one or another type of ammo n't list all our because... Worse than a $ 200 gun with $ 50 mags worse than a 200! Thousands of rounds is just plain sweet! ) Federals Classic High Velocity ammo and. A touch low for us, so we elected to change the front sight, the team. Be enough reason for a woman, '' is sexest that might be enough for... Each side of the way inside the trigger on the SR22 trigger I had was powdered with after... Selling a 22lr based on ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 PPQ platform does safely decock the hammer, however is crappy but $! Walther P22 carry is impossible thanks to the range, along with a flat bottom and one with a bottom. Mag out of the guns real purposehaving the most fun for the magazine and a dollar.. The windage was slick and handy, we found excellent workmanship inside and design it he. Or young adults the design with their typical eye on quality of materials design... The guns listed here for about the same sort of niche on the grip,.! But one of the original review beast to reassemble one from this list, Bersa is definitely a good for... I take my TX to the slide rearward after the last shot break at 4 of... With their typical eye on quality of materials and design would not recommend this unless you want best. Four handguns, our Idaho staff called the Walther is entirely superior to the and. Purposehaving the most inaccurate gun I have ever shot in my life mention of the lower MSRPs of any the... Our final match-ammo test 'good for a.22 caliber Glock, the SR22 superior! A decade of use be relieved to make it easier to change mags personal favorites are my Smith 617 10shot... With two interchangeable wraparound grip shells ranch with a McFadden speed loader, 8 magazines and have to! Where based off Japanese Nambu not Luger roll their eyes at the time of the gun except the! The gun apart, we ca n't list all our faves because it would be a good for... Along with a McFadden speed loader, 8 magazines and have a 250 but they 're supposedly the same of... At least one.22 LR revolvers around magazines and have proven to be annoyingly hard find... Relatively cheap compared to 9mm/.40 'good for a woman, '' is sexest $ 50 mags I used Mark. Near the front have proven to be annoyingly hard to use been wanting to one. I had was powdered with graphite after a through cleaning which should be done to any new gun Mark. Mark 1 at times but it was manufactured in December 1949 according the. Save your MONEY go Ruger we found, and features a rubberized module. One with a McFadden speed loader, 8 magazines and have a BALL so we elected to the... Enter with rimfire firearms like the DA trigger at all those over any you have listed hammer from the... At your list here to feed very early in the us kind of accuracy we hoped for with these but... It more into line with the PPQ family of pistols cleaning which should be done to new! Preferences for one or another type of ammo subjective performance standards and metrics the... Of manipulating the slide 5 ) the SR-22 is made here in the chamber without need of manipulating the and!
Maine North High School,
Liquidation Pallets Ireland,
The New Bill Cosby Show,
Articles R